Fisher Island Rentals

Fisher Island is an ultra-private barrier island accessible only by private ferry, home to the highest per-capita income zip code in the United States.

Highlights

Private ferry access only — no bridge or public access
Historically highest per-capita income zip code in the US
Fisher Island Club Beach Club with private Atlantic beach
216 acres of private tropical island
Cottages, villas, and full-floor condominium residences

Fisher Island Rental Market Snapshot

● Live MLS data · 2026-08-03

Computed from 33 active rental listings in the Miami Association of Realtors MLS.

$28,000/mo

Median Rent

Active Rentals

$13/sqft

Median $/Sq Ft (monthly)

$2,950 – $75,000

Asking Rent Range

Median Rent by Bedroom Count

Beds	Median Rent	Listings	$/Sq Ft Range	Median $/Sq Ft	Avg $/Sq Ft
Studio	$2,950/mo	1 listing	$6.56 – $6.56	$6.56/sqft	$6.56/sqft
2 Bed	$20,000/mo	11 listings	$10.08 – $11.83	$10.85/sqft	$10.85/sqft
3+ Bed	$32,000/mo	21 listings	$6.37 – $11.97	$9.24/sqft	$9.32/sqft

$/sq ft figures are monthly asking rent ÷ living area from active MLS listings (leased “paid” history is not in the public feed). Click a listing count to open the map with that bedroom filter inside the Fisher Island boundary.

Figures reflect active MLS rental inventory and are updated with each data sync. Source: Miami Association of Realtors. Prepared by the MIA.Rentals market-analysis team.

Fisher Island

Fisher Island is a private 216-acre barrier island south of Miami Beach, accessible exclusively by private ferry or helicopter. The island’s zip code has historically ranked as the highest per-capita income in the United States.

What to Expect

Residences range from historic Vanderbilt-era cottages to oceanfront villas and full-floor condominium residences. The Fisher Island Club provides residents with private beach club access, tennis, golf, and spa facilities. Rentals occur exclusively through private agent relationships and are not publicly listed.

Best For

Ultra-high-net-worth individuals who require absolute privacy, security, and the highest standard of island living within minutes of Miami’s core.

Ready to find your Fisher Island rental?

Browse current MLS listings and connect with a local expert.

Browse Fisher Island on Map Talk to an Agent

Brokerage Disclosure

MIA.Rentals is a LAZARO | MIAMI Digital Property owned & operated by Christopher Jorge Lazaro PLLC, a Florida Licensed Real Estate Broker (BK3388297) at Real Broker LLC (CQ1049632). All transactions are brokered by Real Broker LLC, a publicly-traded (NASDAQ: REAX) company. All listings are subject to change without notice and are not guaranteed. Information is deemed reliable but not warranted.

Fair Housing Notice: MIA.Rentals and its affiliated brokers operate in full compliance with federal and Florida Fair Housing laws. We do not discriminate on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, national origin, disability, familial status, or any other protected class.

Listing data is sourced from the Miami Association of Realtors® MLS and is intended for consumers' personal, non-commercial use only. Reproduction or redistribution of MLS data is strictly prohibited. MLS data is updated regularly but may not reflect the most current status of any listing.