Bay Harbor Islands Rental Market Snapshot
● Live MLS data · 2026-08-03 Computed from 127 active rental listings in the Miami Association of Realtors MLS.
$3/sqft
Median $/Sq Ft (monthly)
$1,200 – $25,000
Asking Rent Range
Median Rent by Bedroom Count
| Beds | Median Rent | Listings | $/Sq Ft Range | Median $/Sq Ft | Avg $/Sq Ft |
| Studio | $1,800/mo | 1 listing | — | —/sqft | —/sqft |
| 1 Bed | $2,300/mo | 37 listings | $1.57 – $8.70 | $2.95/sqft | $3.64/sqft |
| 2 Bed | $4,350/mo | 62 listings | $1.87 – $9.68 | $3.46/sqft | $4.21/sqft |
| 3+ Bed | $9,800/mo | 27 listings | $1.89 – $11.19 | $5.19/sqft | $5.46/sqft |
$/sq ft figures are monthly asking rent ÷ living area from active MLS listings (leased “paid” history is not in the public feed). Click a listing count to open the map with that bedroom filter inside the Bay Harbor Islands boundary.
Figures reflect active MLS rental inventory and are updated with each data sync. Source: Miami Association of Realtors. Prepared by the MIA.Rentals market-analysis team.
Why Rent in Bay Harbor Islands?
Bay Harbor Islands is two small islands — East Island and West Island — connected by a bridge over Indian Creek. It has the feel of a small-town village: a walkable main street (Kane Concourse) with cafes, boutiques, and restaurants, surrounded by low-rise residential buildings and a handful of newer condo developments.
What to Expect
Residential stock includes low-rise and mid-rise condo buildings, duplexes, and single-family homes. The town is one of the most walkable small communities in northern Miami-Dade. Bal Harbour Shops is within walking distance, as is the Surfside beach and Surfside town center.
Best For
Those who want a quieter, community-oriented lifestyle at more accessible price points within easy reach of Bal Harbour’s world-class shopping and Miami Beach.
